Hey friends,
New website where I'll be keeping the blog...
www.lethancandlish.com
I'm all official now! And already new entries to look at. Check it out.
Hey friends,
New website where I'll be keeping the blog...
www.lethancandlish.com
I'm all official now! And already new entries to look at. Check it out.
This is an edited transcript of a speech I gave at the Brain Injury Services
Online conference, October 29, 2020 with the topic “Telling Your Story After
Brain Injury.” This speech expands on
many of the ideas that I present in my book, “Who Am I, Now?” and presents a
more complete argument for why storytelling is a useful tool in rehabilitation
after brain injury. I feel the book
presents much of the theory behind my ideas and this speech shares real examples
of how I believe my ideas will work. Please
read, comment, share and enjoy.
Hello, I am Lethan.
When I learned the general topic
for this conference, “Telling your story after brain injury”, I was thrilled --
I am a survivor of traumatic brain injury, I have a Master of Arts degree in Storytelling,
and I recently finished a book about the importance of storytelling after brain
injury. This topic is kinda exactly “my
thing”, so I’m honoured to be able to share some of my thoughts on the subject
with you.
I’m going to start with a quote
by Maya Angelou — “There is no greater agony than bearing an untold story
inside you.”
Hold on to that quote, because
we’re going to come back to it, but I open with it because, when it comes to
brain injury, everyone at this conference has stories. It could be you’re like
me, a survivor, and you have stories about almost dying, rehabilitation, and
the painful long return after brain injury. Or maybe you’re a caregiver and
you’ve got stories about someone you love — a child, spouse, parent — and the
difficulties of providing seemingly endless support
that is not always appropriately appreciated. Or maybe you’re a doctor, nurse,
lawyer, friend, colleague — whatever the case, we’ve all got stories, but most
times these stories are never shared, and we keep them inside for a bunch of
reasons.
For one, these are difficult
stories. Medically and emotionally complicated, confusing — we probably don’t
fully understand everything that happened or is still happening. And second, it’s hard to find someone who’s
able to listen — it’s not the sort of thing you use to start off
a conversation on the street — “Hey, how you doing? Good? That’s great!
Let me tell you about my brain injury” — that’s not done. To tell these stories you’ve got to find the
right time, place, and it takes work.
Furthermore, these stories do not
show you in your best light — I don’t care if you’re a survivor or caregiver or
whatever, the stories get dark, and I’m certain there are some times when you
acted in a manner that you’re probably not particularly proud of. No shame for whatever happened, but it does
make the story harder to tell.
And then there are all the other
reasons to avoid storytelling in general — fear of public speaking, not being
sure of “How do I tell a story”, respecting confidentiality. There are a lot of reasons we don’t tell
stories about brain injury, but these stories of survival are stories that Must
be Told.
I have this idea, and I call it
my Big Idea, because I’ve been dedicated
to reading, writing, and philosophizing about it for the past six years, and five
years before that I started with a master’s thesis performance project about
TBI, so I’ve been mulling this idea over for quite some time.
But this Big Idea is – Storytelling should be used as a tool in
rehabilitation after traumatic brain injury for three reasons:
1) Storytelling provides inspiration for survivors;
2) Assists with the process of reintegration into
a community after the initial hospital rehabilitation;
3) and Helps with the acceptance and appreciation
of self-identity after brain injury.
In this speech, I’m going to
explain my Big Idea by telling the
story of what inspired it, and elaborating on each of those three points along
the way; this will then be followed by suggestions of how you can prepare and
tell your story about brain injury.
That said, this is a story, so...
Once upon a time...
In 2008 I was in graduate school,
studying storytelling, and getting ready to begin work on my master’s thesis
performance project when I was introduced to the Crumley House Brain Injury
Rehabilitation and Living Center. Already a survivor of brain injury, I had
entered the storytelling graduate program with the intention of creating a
piece about my brain injury for the required performance thesis project, but at
the time it was just an idea. My thought
process was something akin to, “Oh, I had a brain injury and I survived —
that’s probably a pretty good story...” but I had nothing more than that. So,
when fate introduced me to the Crumley House, I thought this could be a good
opportunity to learn more about brain injury, maybe find some inspiration for
the piece, and get to know other survivors.
I began to visit the
rehabilitation and living center two or three times a month — about every other
week — volunteering as a storyteller to share some fun folktale performances
and, more importantly, to talk about my experience as a survivor. It was through sharing my experiences of
recovery that I began to see the healing power of storytelling.
These were unrehearsed,
unprepared stories that were pulled from choppy memories that were lodged deep
in recesses of my mind, but by returning to these stories in the company of
fellow survivors, I was able to recall some deeply filed events and emotions with
new clarity. Furthermore, what I found
amazing was that the residents at the Crumley House understood what I was
talking about and we began to have conversations that shared similar emotional
experiences. Up until that point, I hadn’t interacted with many other brain
injury survivors – not as a conscious avoidance, but because I hadn’t been
aware of any opportunities and hadn’t actively sought out fellow survivors –
and to have people understand these events, and share stories of similar
experiences that, until then, I had thought were unique was amazing!
We’re talking about emotional
experiences that a lot of survivors will probably understand, but are unknown
to people not familiar with brain injury. For example:
- Having a stew of emotions mish-mashed and
constantly simmering in your head — and it’s a stew of exuberance and joyful
celebration for the fact that you are alive, mixed with disgust and rage for
the fact that you’re still living, stirred with appreciation and love for all
the people who are caring for you, and the spite toward every aspect of the universe
for leaving you stuck in this oppressively solipsistic situation, and then
there is this huge chunk of pure apathy plopped on top that coats the whole
thing. And trying to explain this stew is the only honest answer you could give
if a caregiver asks, “Hey, how you doing today?” but being unable to coherently express this
mess, when you’re asked the question, you say, “Me? I’m fine, I guess.”
- Or the frustration at having to relearn things I
knew I should know how to do. Like walking.
I remember, walking technique — heal, toe, heal, toe — yet how hard this
simple task was. And then there’s this shameful sense of accomplishment when
being congratulated for successfully completing this rudimentary task.
- And the embarrassment at the over expression of emotions. Any emotion
— joy, anger, sorrow, excitement — it’s this volcano with a lava flow of
emotion erupting, making everyone around uncomfortable and meanwhile, there’s
this reason, this rationality that’s aware and watching from back of your mind
going, “No, no, no — this is too much — no, that’s not right.”
And the survivors at the Crumley
House would hear me describe these experiences, understand what I’m talking
about, and then tell about their own experiences — things I could relate to and
understand. We had this conversation, a
conversation where we share the fact that we’re on this journey together.
And that brings me to the first
point of my Big Idea — that
storytelling inspires survivors. And this idea works in two ways.
First, and I think this is the
most obvious way that storytelling can be used as a tool, there’s the
inspiration that comes from a survivor who’s had a good recovery experience
sharing his or her story. And this is important
– it is why speakers are invited to conferences such as this – to share the
experience of someone who has been through parts of recovery and who has worked
through challenges that other survivors might be experiencing. Someone who’s not a therapist, not a teacher,
not a friend saying, “It’s going to be alright,” — but someone who can say,
“No, this sucks. It’s not going to magically ‘go away’ when you get all
better. Brain injury is a part of you
now, but know that this new part is okay.” We need inspirational storytellers
to show that brain injury is not an ending of anything. As I said before, this is actually one of the
main reasons I was first invited to visit the Crumley House, the staff and
residents hoped I could help to provide inspiration, but what we didn’t realize
is that this is only part of how sharing stories works.
You’ll remember that I said that
the conversation went both ways? When visiting, I would share what I remembered
of my experience, and then a resident would be reminded of his or her
experience, and this might remind another resident of an experience, and then
another resident, or me...and whenever I would share my stories of recovery it
was the stories that were shared in response that I found the most
rewarding. And since I’ve begun to speak
at some brain injury survivor’s conferences, the experience has been the same –
it’s the stories heard from fellow survivors that continue to teach me about my
own healing process.
For years after my injury, I
thought that my story was unique. I
remember hearing time and time again how the experience of recovery after brain
injury is different for every person and
there can be no timeline for how long it will take or what the healing will
actually be, and this information is true, but what I don’t remember hearing —
and I don’t know if I wasn’t told or if I just didn’t listen — but what I
didn’t hear was that there are events
and emotional experiences that, while maybe not universal, are at the very
least not uncommon. Similar vents in recovery that may seem unique actually
happen to many people.
By sharing stories with fellow survivors — that’s telling stories and
hearing stories — I learned that navigating the experience of recovery after
brain injury isn’t so much like you’re trekking through a jungle of unknowns,
but more like you’re on a path that’s been travelled before — treacherous and
you’ve got jungle on either side, but people have used it before, and if you’re
careful, you should make it through just fine.
So in terms of my graduation
project, this is good. I’m gathering
stories and getting a start on my performance thesis’s project. The stories I
hear from residents are stories I relate to and understand, and I’ve begun
sorting through memories from my own experience. These are not composed stories, but are
mostly told off the cuff
as they spill out in story sharing conversations – vague, emotional,
half-memories – and I realize I should write them down. This would be material the performance project
—it is, after all, going to be a storytelling about my injury.
And I get a notepad and start
scribbling thoughts, phrases – figuring out what sort of storyline I can put
pull from this process – and I realize that there is a lot about my accident, especially
early recovery, that I don’t know. I
guess it makes sense that I don’t know what happened, I was in a coma after
all, and after that my memory wasn’t too hot, so I decided I needed to talk to
the people who were there — family and friends who were a part of that time in
my life. I figured they could help to
tell me my story.
During the holiday semester
break, I went back to my hometown and scheduled times to talk with family and
friends, and a lot of people were very generous in sharing their time, but no
one could tell my story. Not-a-one. Turns
out, when I asked them about what was happening at this time, everyone told me
their own story. It’s funny to say that
now, but I had been so focused on My
story and My accident, that it
hadn’t occurred to me that, Of Course
everyone had other things going on.
Everyone had their own set of challenges in dealing with my recovery
once I left the rehabilitation hospital, like:
-
My parents having to drive me everywhere and make sure I got to all the
doctors’ appointments and check-ups that were still going, while also dealing
with their own careers, and making sure my younger sister was alright and taken
care of…
- and my Sister, needing to find ways to not feel
like she’s being forgotten amid the drama. It seemed like everyone was focused
on her brother, but she was thirteen at the time, just becoming a teenager and
trying to find groups that are safe and can support her with healthy
friendships
- and my Friends, I mean, here’s this person
they’ve known for years, and now he’s out of the hospital, but acting all weird
and behaving in a way that’s just not right some of the time, or a lot of the
time, and they don’t understand what’s going on.
And then, turns out, everyone
also had difficulties that had nothing
to do with me. Jobs, school, family, romance — Life Happened, and it turns out that,
for most people, I wasn’t the center of everything.
Along with this, I realized how
much other people didn’t know about my story — how many people didn’t
understand that rehabilitation goes on for years after brain injury. Truth is,
the people around me were looking at someone whom they had known and loved for
years, but now this person was acting really different. Yeah, they figured it had something to do
with brain injury, but they didn’t know why or how. For me, as the survivor, I was just trying to act normally, but it didn’t
seem “normal” to everyone around me, and it could get really
uncomfortable. So, when I asked my
family and friends what happened from their perspective, turns out they viewed
everything in a manner that was completely different from how I viewed
myself. It’s silly how obvious this is now, but turns out we all had different
stories.
And that brings me to the second
point of my Big Idea — that
storytelling can help with reintegration into the community after brain injury.
Now, much like providing inspiration for fellow survivors, this is also about
the conversation that stems from storytelling and works in two ways.
First, there’s the
storyteller-survivor telling his or her story to the community to inform the
community about the experience of recovery after TBI. This is important because people need to
understand that recovery takes months or years of focused rehabilitation after
a survivor leaves the hospital or rehabilitation clinic; also, community
members should be made aware that a survivor will never return to being “the
same as before” – most people simply do not know either of these facts. And it is not the communities fault that
there is so little understanding of the realities of recovery because the idea
of a complete recovery is something that is consistently fed to us by the media
— TV and movies almost always show a hero surviving this huge, massive
explosion-collision-calamity, and they’re knocked unconscious — head trauma —go
to the hospital, and the hero wakes up a few days or weeks later and everyone’s
gathered around — “Oh my God, you’re Alive! You pulled through! How do you
feel?”
“Me, I’m…uh, I don’t remember
what happened...everything’s kinda a blur...wait, wait, hold on...okay, now I’m
ready to go and Save the World.”
And often in the news, when
there’s a story about head trauma the focus of the coverage is on whether the
person lives. Living is most important,
no doubt, but the story about the long gruelling recovery process is generally passed
over and just ignored. As an
entertainer, I sort of understand why this is done, because the story
rehabilitation after brain injury doesn’t make for good TV — it’s a slow,
arduous process that usually doesn’t have the “Big Show Event”, finale, or grand
conclusion. Instead, recovery just keeps
happening, getting a little bit better, day by day, week by week, year by year
— and it’s not good TV.
But, again, this is why stories
about recovery after brain injury must be told, so that communities can have a
better understanding of the extended process of rehabilitation after TBI. With
this knowledge a community can better prepare for and adapt to the needs of a
survivor. People can understand more
about the long process after leaving the hospital and be more prepared to
accept and support a survivor in his or her journey
Now, to be clear, I do not view
this part of my Bit Idea of using
storytelling as an immediate solution for any one person — it’s not as though a
survivor can emerge from the hospital, become a storyteller, immediately tell
the story as part of rehabilitation, and then everyone in the community will
say, “Oh yeah, you know, I get it, let’s all behave differently,”
– that’s not going to happen. But if
more survivors share stories of recovery, it provides more reference points in
the world that people can look to for information. It makes information about the extended
process of recovery something people in a community might have already heard
about.
So that’s an extended hope for
the future, a way that using storytelling to gather more examples of recovery
can help a larger community, but like I said, this part of my Big Idea is about the conversation. The other way storytelling helps with
reintegration into a community is when a storyteller-survivor is preparing the
storytelling piece. During this
preparation, if done in the most fulfilling manner, the storyteller will talk
to friends and family who were part of the experience, and this will help the
survivor hear new perspectives on his or her own story.
It’s easy for the story of
recovery to seem to be all about the survivor.
Especially for a survivor, it can easily seem as if everyone in the
world is focused on your recovery. This
can cause an ego-centric focus to develop, where the thought process becomes,
“This is what I did, this is what I went through, and everyone else was just
around me.” The struggles of countless
other people who are affected by the injury are
forgotten. Taking the time to speak with
and acknowledge the journey of other people can make it easier for a survivor
to find new ways to return to the community.
Before brain injury, a person
generally had a way of “gelling with” or interacting with a community that was
just known, but when brain injury happens this unconsciously understood way of
working together comes apart. After the
injury, a lot of times all the different sides are trying to
fit things back together in the same way as before, but the pieces have
changed, and this can cause clashes and discomfort – no one is happy. When
preparing for a storytelling, the survivor is able to look at the events with a
new perspective and listening to people who were part of the recovery process, allowing
the recovery to be seen from a new angle.
This can help to show the new ways in which the survivor needs to
interact with a community and can allow people to come together and find more
inclusive ways to support healing. It’s
important to remember that brain injury doesn’t just happen to a person, but it
happens to a community.
Back to the story of my graduate
thesis – now I have three piles of stories: those from fellow survivors that I
relate to, but stories that I’m not in at all; from friends and family that I
was a part of, but I don’t really understand the experiences in the same way;
and personal half-memories from the time in rehabilitation and returning to the
community. It’s a lot of information,
but it didn’t all make sense to me yet, and I needed to put it all together to make
a unified performance piece.
I decide to lay out narratives I had. Literally. I write a short script for each
story-memory — those collected and the stories I remembered, and then worked to
split the longer memories into even smaller moments by trimming each memory and
shaping it as a short anecdote depicting an incident in recovery. Once I the stories had been documented, I took
each snippet and tried piecing them together with the goal of discovering a way
in which they can be combined to create a fuller storytelling piece. It’s like
having a table puzzle spread out before me, and I’m trying to put all the edge
pieces together so that I can see the beginning a structure of what’s eventually
going to be the larger picture. And this
worked, as I found a way to arrange an outline, and then took all the pieces
left and started inserting them in a way that filled in some of the empty
space. This worked, and the story began
to form, but there were still big chunks of the puzzle where I still couldn’t
see the picture — parts where I still don’t understand what happened, but
decided that I would come back to that later.
Reflecting on what I did have, I
started to see that my storytelling piece needed to be about change —
especially after talking with my family and friends who witnessed big changes
in my attitude – and I saw that this storytelling needed to address who I was
before the injury and then who I am now, so I made the goal of the piece to
provide an explanation of how I made that transformation. But this had the
side-effect of causing me to ponder, “Well, okay but Who am I?
And to have this question come up
was hard, because it took me back to the memory of how variations of the
question pounding on me when I was in early recovery — questions of self-identity
— questions that I had never really dealt with but that I had stuffed
into one of the closets of my mind, one of those closets where you shove
everything that you just don’t want to deal with — but now, as part of my
thesis project and by looking at all the gaps in the story, turns out I had to
open up that closet and all those questions just came crashing down on me
again. I had to deal with what fell out
by picking apart each question so that I could successfully fill in the gaps of
the story. It was hard, but I figure,
“Hey, I’m a storyteller, this is what I do.”
The requirement for my master’s thesis project was to create a
performance that an audience can follow and understand, and as part of that, I
had to create a story I understand.
With this mind, I began to
construct a story that filled in what I didn’t understand. The story had elements of fiction, because I
had to invent some events to fill in the gaps, but it was in no a fantasy. Instead, I did my research and learned events
that could have happened and logically explained the story segments that I
didn’t have enough information to understand. Then, with these options, I made choices about
what would fit with my situation and created a plausible story about the events
of my injury and recovery that answered any questions in my head. With the intention of creating a storytelling
piece that an audience could understand, I first had to answer any questions of
self-identity for myself. I had to acknowledge and accept who I became after my
brain injury, and more importantly, appreciate who I am now.
Which brings me to the third part
of my Big Idea — that storytelling can help with the acceptance and
appreciation of self-identity after brain injury.
Getting into this claim, we first
need to establish what is self-identity, because that’s a pretty heady concept.
I mean, when we look at pictures of ourselves, we can say that is a picture of
me. I see pictures of myself as a young child, a teenager, a young adult, a
married man, and the persons in all of these pictures are nothing alike — different
looks, different attitudes, different
abilities, different preferences — but I
know that all those people are me and I have no problem defending such a claim.
That’s amazing, but how does that work? How is it easily accepted that all
these strikingly different people have the same identity.?
I hold that it is a person’s
story that is his or her self-identity. The changes that happen in a person
over time can be accounted for because there is a consistent storyline that
accounts for these changes happening in a gradual manner. In some cases there may even be a specific
event that leaves a mark on the storyline of a person and accounts for a
definite, somewhat monumental change, but it is something that can be defined,
can be recognized, can be pointed to and you can say this the moment when that
change happened.
With changes after brain injury,
there is no real moment like that. A person is usually going about a pretty
normal day, a lot of times there is nothing really exceptional happening, then
....Whish... the
person starts getting awareness again in a completely different
place.
And it is not a matter of opening
your eyes and wondering where you are — we talked about this earlier — but
whatever they show in the movies is not how it happens for most people. It’s a
matter of already being awake and slowly memories begin to stick again — for
me, I was awake for almost three weeks before any memories decided to actually
remain in my brain. And when my memories began to stick there wasn’t a shock to
learn I had received brain injury – I assume I had already learned this even
though I have no memory of the injury or of learning about the injury. That was simply the condition in which I came
to awareness, but there was no event I could pick out that explained how I got
there. Yes, I knew I had been in an accident and I knew there was brain injury,
but those were things I was told about — there was no memory in my mind that I
could point to and say, “This is what caused the changes that put me in my
current condition.”
Now, that’s how it happened for
me, and from my research and interactions, I suspect that’s how it happens for
a lot of survivors — you don’t sudden learn, “Oh my God, I have brain injury!”
but you come back to awareness with your brain injury being an understood
condition. However, as I was working on
this speech, I realized I don’t actually know the facts about that — there’s
nothing I can cite with that information — so I am curious what the experience
is for other survivors. So, to all the survivors I ask, was there any moment of
revelation for you when you came back after brain injury? Or was it more like I
described — where your awareness returned slowly and your condition was already
understood. Please feel free to leave a
comment about this, as I am very curious.
But returning to the topic,
regardless of how the awareness returned, when it returns, changes have
happened. To add to the confusion, a lot
of times these changes won’t be recognized at first — everyone is focused on
the survivor being alive, so that any changes that do come out may simply be
overlooked or marked off as something that will go
away soon. And then the survivor continues to heal, eventually returns back to
his or her home community, begins the return to a normal life, and the survivor
is trying to act normal but...
I think about it like this —
imagine you have this bag labelled “normal behaviours” that you always reach
into when deciding how to behave. These are behaviours that have been developed
over years of actions and habits and gradual changes that occur as a result of
life events. Then, when brain injury happens, all the behaviours in this “bag”
are swapped out for a different set of behaviours there
are new behaviours similar to your previous set, but more extreme and less
filtered. As a survivor, you don’t know that this switch happened. You’re
reaching into the same place to grab a response or a reaction, but instead of
the action that everyone is familiar with, you pull out one of these new,
unfiltered behaviours. And friends and family might not be comfortable with
these new behaviours, or may even be downright offended. This new set can
even cause the people to comment on how you’ve changed and you’re not like you
“used to be”, yet you’re reaching into the same bag for “normal behaviours” and
they are not coming out in correct manner.
You ask the people you know, “Hey, so what about me is different?”
And they might respond, “I don’t know, it’s just you — I mean, you just act and do things differently.
It just doesn’t seem like you. It’s just, I don’t know, it’s just you’re not
like — You.”
And this is hell: being told by
people you love and trust that You are not like You.
There’s been a change — the brain
injury has caused a change in temperament and attitudes and physical ability
and...and there is no series of events on the personal timeline, no moment in
the memory, that explains these changes. No wonder there’s identity confusion
after brain injury. And this is how storytelling can help. By creating an
organized, logical story, a survivor is able to have an understanding of what
happened — is able to fill in that big empty gap of memory and to create an
understanding of what happened. While it
is better to do research by interviewing people who witnessed the accident and
recovery, there will still be parts that no one tells you about, parts that the
storyteller/survivor must create and fill in with an imaginary, but plausible
explanation. When you’re making a
storytelling piece, you’re creating an understanding of what happened that
allows you to be who you are now.
In my experience, when I was
working on my storytelling piece it was a powerful transformation to come to
this understanding. Brain injury was no longer an event that just happened to
me, but by turning it into a story, I was able make brain injury something that
I had experienced, recovery something that I am still experiencing, and all of
it a part of Who I am Now.
Now I’ve laid out this Big Idea —
how storytelling can be a beneficial tool for rehabilitation after brain injury
and I hope I’ve given you an idea of what my thoughts are and what I hope to
continue to study in my life.
All that said, I’m going to
return to the quote I told you hang on to at the beginning of this speech — by
Maya Angelou,
“There is no greater agony than
bearing an untold story inside you.”
As a survivor, this quote speaks
to me in many ways.
Because there’s the agony of
keeping your story inside you because you think no one will understand it — how
alone that makes you feel. And how freeing it is when you finally share that
story with other survivors — people who have experienced the same thing.
Then there’s the agony of trying
to return to a community where every person has a different
story and is looking at you differently, and your trying to
put these stories together but nothing is fitting right. Then getting the chance to hear the stories
of the people around you, and perhaps letting them hear more of your story, and
how this leads to a happier and healthier return.
And there’s the agony of not
having the complete story — not having Your complete
story — not knowing who you are. But then there’s the release when you take the
time to put your story together in a way that lets you understand your injury
as something that experienced and as part of what makes you — You.
To finish up the story of my
thesis project, the piece I finally composed and performed became titled, Who Am I, Again? a verbal collage of stories
about severe traumatic brain injury.
For this piece I used parts of the story of my recovery as a frame and
then pulled in stories from fellow survivors, family, and friends to highlight
shared experiences of recovery that occur after brain injury. And the
performance was a success. Not only did I graduate, but for the initial
performance I was able to invite the residents at the Crumley House and share
my interpretation of their stories, and everyone seem to love it. To be able to
share that experience was a powerful honour.
And it turns out that the
performance was just a step in a larger story — because I continued to perform
about brain injury at several locations around the US for a couple of years,
which led to me writing a blog, which eventually led to my book that has
brought me to where I am now, continuing to write and refine my thoughts about
storytelling as a tool for rehabilitation.
It’s all part of a big story, and it makes me think of something my first
storytelling mentor told me:
His name is Karl and he has a
storytelling company that I worked for in the summers as a student, and one day
he called me onto the porch of the theatre where we performed, and Karl said,
“Lethan, you know, storytelling is looking at a moment from a story, and
deciding why it is beautiful.”
So, I hope this talk inspires you
to look at your story — the story of recovery from brain injury or the story of
a caring for someone you love — and I hope you look at some of those moments,
maybe even the hardest moments, and decide why
they are beautiful.
Okay, now we’ve gone through the
theoretical, philosophical part of the speech — explaining the Big Idea — and you may be thinking,
“Those ideas make a lot of sense and storytelling could be a really helpful
part of my recovery — but how do I do that?” For this final part of my speech,
I’m going to lay out a few things you can do to start planning how you want to
tell your story of recovery. Keep in mind, we only have time for some starting
steps today. I do intend to follow up with some more publications outlining
this process, so please do follow my blog and I do hope to write a companion,
“How To” book so feel free to follow me on Amazon — but right now I’m going to
share a few steps that can help you begin the process of sharing your story.
The first thing to do is to find
a group of people with whom you can share your story. As I mentioned at the
start of this speech, stories about recovery are really hard for an unprepared
person to listen to, so it’s important that you have people who will devote the
time and attention to hearing what you have to say. This groups can be made up
of family, friends, therapists, fellow survivors — anyone who is will to share
some time with you. You are welcome to open your performance to the public, but
you don’t have to. The presentation can
also be a private event among people you trust, it is entirely up to you. What is important is that you do have some sort
of audience, because having an audience creates the requirement of having other
people understand the story. If you’re composing the story for just yourself,
there can be overwhelming emotions that cloud the reality of what happened. I’m
not saying ignore these emotions, but by forcing yourself to compose a story
for other people helps to pull the author out of the emotional memory and focus
more objectively on what happened while still acknowledging emotions that were
present and how these affected what happened.
I also want to be clear that,
when you perform your storytelling, it does not necessarily mean that you need
to share a memorize piece. You need to plan to do what is most comfortable for
you, and if you like memorizing a script, that’s fine, or maybe you want to have
an outline of the story that you follow but the words are spontaneous, or maybe
you want a paper in front of you that you can hold and recite your story to an
audience. I don’t think that how you tell your story is important. What is important is that it is spoken in a
live performance so that you can be a witness to the journey of that experience
in your head being translated into words and then passed through the body to be
released into the air as language that flies and lands among the audience, and
then you can see how these words affect other people. It is
powerful to know that your story is heard and understood.
Once you have a planned audience,
set yourself a date for the performance. There is no requirement for how soon
or how far away this date should be, but setting a date gives you a deadline
that you need to meet, and having a deadline helps to ensure that the
performance will happen. I know that I need deadlines or else I’m never fully
satisfied with my work.
That said, while setting a
deadline is important, understand that if you need to extend your deadline for
any reason, that’s also okay. Life happens, things come up, and sometimes a
deadline you set for yourself is a little too ambitious. Give yourself a hard
deadline to follow, but don’t be angry if you need to adjust. A deadline is
intended to help and motivate you, not to be a hinderance. Also, for your first deadline, I recommend
giving yourself at least 4 months to
work, and it is probably better to have at least 6 months. This is a long
project, and part of the goal of this project is to give yourself time to
really explore the memory of your early recovery and see what you can learn
from it. Deciding how your story is
beautiful can be a difficult task and will require some serious work.
I recommend stating with those
steps because it gives you a clear goal to meet. After that, you’re onto the
creative part, and to get those creative juices flowing, I start a reflective
journal. Write down your initial thoughts about this project, and start
reaching into your memories, writing down anything you can recall having to do
with recovery. This is not for a
performance script and does not need to be understood by an audience, so for
this initial part of brain storming, an audience understanding is not
required. This is just for you. You may want to share with someone, and
that’s fine, but it does not need to be the goal of this journal. Write the memories however they come to you.
Get your thoughts out, and see if they bring up any other memories. Just start
writing and see where it takes you.
Along with these journal entries,
I recommend talking with other people — talk with fellow survivors, or family
and friends who have been part of your recovery process — share memories and
thoughts, and then journal some more.
You may have figured this out
already, but I think journaling is a really important part of the early
creative process. This can help you be aware as your story changes, and by
going back and reviewing some of these journal entries, it can help you to get
over some creative humps that are causing trouble in the creation of the
storytelling.
From there, there are no
boundaries to how you compose your piece. Again, I remind you that it is
helpful to remember that you are composing this for an audience, so you need to
be understood, and for that reason, I do recommend you schedule time to
rehearse with a friend or mentor at least
once or twice in the creation process, but it could happen much more often. Work with someone you trust will be honest
about your art, and use this person to make sure that your story can be
understood.
I also recommend that you
play. Play with your memories and the
material you wrote as you work with on the storytelling. Try speaking with a
new voice — try moving in a new way — try rearranging the scenes— try inserting
new scenes... remember that while you’re trying to create a performance to
share with other people, part of the growth in this project is what you can
learn along the way.
Those are just a few starting
ideas of how to do this sort of project.
I’ll be writing and publishing more as I have the time, so please do
stay in touch through my blog.
I am alone and in Malaysia this holiday season due to a series of circumstances that are irrelevant to this article, but I want that to be understood as context while I relate this story. Know that I am healthy, safe and trying to remain optimistic about future plans, but simply put, it sucks. I did share a internet video chat with my parents and sister in the States and my wife who is currently in China, but I wanted to mark the holiday by doing different, so I decided go for a hike early Christmas morning, and using the power of the internet I found a large hill/small mountain named Broda Hill that I could visit.
Taking a taxi to the base of the park, I arrived just as the sun was beginning to stretch and promptly walked to a ticket entrance where I learned that some of the steeper trails had fallen into disrepair and not all of the scenic areas were open. This meant that, according to the official statement by the workers behind the ticketing counter, I should not even try to reach the top of the mountain, the spot that contained the views that had been advertised. I could still trek through the jungle and see whatever views were there, and the ticket takers promised that there would be spots for pictures, just not the panorama I had intended to see. Having already paid the taxi for the commute, and with no other plans, I accepted the restrictions and continued with my planned hike. My philosophy is generally to say ‘yes’ to any event and attempt to appreciate whatever occurs. For the most part, this has resulted in good choices, but you never know, but I try to aim forward because I’ve already seen behind me.
And the hike was fine. There were a few other people on the trail that took me uphill, but for the most part everything was suitably quiet. It was pretty. I was walking through the mildly cultivated jungle, marching along a steep the hill side, finding foliage framed views of Malaysian farmland lit by a morning tropical sun that was resting atop the mountains on the other side of the valley.
Having barricaded myself in an apartment for most of the last month with the aim of keeping safe from disease, I enjoyed the fresh air and the packed dirt paths, but was disappointed that I wouldn’t see the sites from the top of the hill. Actually, let’s be fair, “disappointed” might be too strong a word, as the melancholy that came from the lack of a holiday mood brewed apathy more than anything else, so I wasn’t really disappointed, but I did have a strong sense of, “Eh, well that sucks.”
I walked until I couldn’t find a trial, and then turned around. It had been maybe an hour and a half, but the sun was now fully in the sky and people were beginning to populate the path. Finding a side trail that went uphill on the right, I decided to explore, and soon this turned into a climb up the mountain. I was moving toward a peak that may be officially closed, as advised by the ticketing workers, but I observed several groups attempting to navigate a way up the steep rocks.
I thought, “Why not?” and began to climb. Carefully setting each foot before any movement and relying on my hands for support, I was able to begin the ascent. It was tricky, but a tinge of excitement began to percolate in my body, for this was something new and presented what could be a Christmas challenge. The rocks grew less stable, the ascent steeper, and when I was about a third of the way up I stopped to refresh myself with some water and decipher my next steps. Small pebbles coated the larger rocks, making the stone slick as ice and near impossible for my road-running shoes to grip any surface,. There seemed to be two potential routes up the hill, right or left. I’m right handed, so I attempted the right path first — it looked steeper, and would require more work with my hands, but it also seemed to have fewer rocks and would create less danger of slipping. The gaps between the rocks, however, were too large, and after about fifty meters, I turned around. I might have been able to keep going, but decided to at least look at the path on the left before deciding what course to take.
I found the same ledge where I could rest and survey the situation. As I recouped with more water, I watched as a group of young men, perhaps 15 years younger than I, came from the top of the mountain and navigated their way down the steep slope. I was trying to see the path they took and consider if I might follow it in reverse, when I heard the slick sound of rock on rock and watched as one of the hikers lost the grip with his shoe and began to skid down the mountain with an avalanche of pebbles skirting after him. Now, he did not seem shocked by his slip — may have even planned it — and stayed calm as he surfed past me, going down the mountain for another 10 to 15 meters for a total ride of about 40 meters. His cool and calm was impressive, but when his feet found a solid grip again, it felt like everyone watching nearby breathed a collective sigh of relief and his wide eyed friends let out a nervous and relieved gaggle of laughter and then returned to focusing on how to make their own, more cautious decent.
There was never any serious danger. Everyone was fine and the “great stone slide” will likely be forgotten by the youthful hikers, but I stayed on my safe perch and began to run some numbers.
First, I would probably be fine going up the steep hill. Definitely at least a 50% chance that nothing went wrong — no, probably better than that...at least 60%, maybe even a 70% likelihood that I could climb the steep, mountain-ish hill and nothing of note would occur. Assuming that is what would happen, I mount the summit and witness a beautiful panorama from the peak. No doubt, that would be...nice. I had seen internet previews and didn’t expect a mind-blowing or life rejuvenating experience, but it would fun. There would be a good view, I would pause, sip water, ponder the majestic quality of nature while I caught my breath, look around and realize I had no one to share the moment with, and begin to climb down. It would be, eh... nice. And I am in relatively good shape, so I would probably be if fine — I’ll revise my numbers and give it a 75-80% chance that I’m fine.
But then I thought about the alternative. According to my presumptuous calculations, there was a 20-25% chance something might happen. This something might not be THAT bad, but...I mean probably not, but who knows? It could very well be that in some possible future there was a chance that I would also surf down the rock, but instead of using shoes with improper tread, I would use my face — not likely, but not impossible. And there was also a chance that I might drop my cellphone down the side, loose my water, bust my jeans... Or I could ignore this risk and prove myself...to myself...in a solipsistic ego stroke...and I would see a view would be...eh...probably nice.
I’ve had the privilege of seeing countless “nice views” in my life. Sometimes these views come from a long hike in through a forest and other times from a short stroll around town, but regardless I have seen thousands of “nice views”, and probably hundreds of truly spectacular landscapes. What’s more, I hope and expect to see as many or more such sites in the future, as long as I don’t prematurely end my ability to take in such experiences by surfing down a mountain side and not sticking the landing — this is especially true when I’m stuck in a country without insurance. The climb would possibly lead to one more new, “nice view” that I could add to the stack of thousands, or I skip it and be assured safety. I made a choice, and did not to climb. I would have probably likely been fine, but did I need to take the risk? The future awaits.
I include this story in my blog about survival because it is an example of recognizing limits. As survivor, I try not to let anything stand in my way — I want to push my abilities to their fullest, and no one can say that brain injury has limited my life experiences. More importantly, I push myself because I don’t want to consider the idea that my injury has hindered any of my choices. I want to know that I am fully living life. This is important, and I encourage all survivors create, face, and attempt challenges — push yourself to do more than you did yesterday, try what hasn’t been done, see new things, but realize some tasks are just too dangerous or dumb to do, and know that not doing everything does not mean you have failed, it means you have thought about it. That’s how I looked at my decision not to climb the mountain — I didn’t have a safety network, I didn’t have the gear, I didn’t have the experience, and I might have probably been fine, but I can forgo one nice experience to ensure experiences in the future when I am better prepared.
This revelation was my self-given Christmas gift. I’m getting older — nearing 40 — and while my body might not be able to bounce off rocks with the elasticity of youth, I will accept the wisdom that I’m finding as a supplement that previously imagined invincibility.
(The photos added are from that hike. The first is from a safe spot on the trail, the second is from my perch part way up the climb — it doesn’t really give a full perspective of the difficulty, but you can see the slick pebbles on the rocks.)
Rage is an issue for me. It has been for all my life, but especially since my brain injury. It’s taken a lot of work, but now I am at least conscious of the dangers rage can create, and I am actively working on finding ways calm any impulses, yet there have been times when it seems that I foresee when a rage will consume me — as if I can predict the future. It’s a vision in my head that dictates what will occur to ignite my temper. I do not have this sort of vision often, anymore, but when such a vision does find me it will almost inevitably come true.
Since I’ve recognized that this premonition occurs, absurd questions have popped up. Am I psychic? Can I predict the future? Is there any way to use this talent to make some money?
Recently, a rage struck me. It was not in anyway dangerous — no one was harmed, no relationships were damaged, but I did used crude, immature language toward another person because the company that person worked for was attempting to cheat me out of several hundred US dollars — I ordered a product that wasn’t delivered and the company acknowledged that the product wasn’t delivered, but they were not refunding my payment. There was legitimate reason to be angry. As the situation began to play out I had a vision, and I knew exactly what I would say to this person if they didn’t adhere to the guarantees that had been promised. I envisioned exactly how the rage would strike and what venom would spew from my tongue. This was repeated many times on the movie screen of my mind, and at times it would even inspire me to vocalize my anger as I expressed myself to the walls of my apartment with passionate tones, as if I was shouting at the villain while watching a TV program. And it was very much like criticizing the TV because my vocalizations had no effect — there was nothing I could do to stop it — as it was a vision of what would occur.
So when the worker contacted me to give me bad information, as predicted, and reported the company’s hesitancy in refunding the payment I made, and my vision came true. The words that had been screened in my mind dozens of times were recited with exactly the same vehemence I had foreseen. My vision came to pass and I verbally raged at this person. The immature spite that spewed out didn’t change anything, for better or worse, but it did stain my name.
I am ashamed and embarrassed when a rage strikes. As I said, I am working to calm these impulses, so when this happened I asked, why? How could I predict this? If I had foreseen such an action, why couldn’t I stop it?
In the hope of calming my anger and deciphering answers to my questions, I went for a run. It was a terrible run, for anger had already drained my body of energy, but as my feet pounded the pavement, I pondered through possible reasons for my loss of control. Again and again my feet hit the road and again and again potential reasons scrolled through my mind.
As I said, the run was not good, but I did run, and I was able to do some sort of run because I had done it before. Again and again. It is a habit of mine.
Again and again. The reasons for my rage played in my mind. It was a habit.
Realization!
My “vision” had been playing continuously in my head. Again and again. I hadn’t predicted my rage, I had rehearsed it. My mind had used what was known to anticipate what would likely happen, and then concocted a response based on my history — I had a history of rage, so it assumed I would rage. With this decision made, the scene that might happen was played with obsessive repetition and ingrained itself in my memory. Therefore, when the reality revealed itself to be close to what had been predicted — the introduction to the scene — I knew exactly how to act in order to make the “vision” come true. I said my lines, flailed my arms, and appeared as an ass.
I don’t like that, and my recognition of this tendency allows me to make a choice. When my mind predicts a shameful response to some situation, I must be aware, and instead of accepting the scene as a prediction, I can decide what alternatives might occur. How can the scene play out in a manner that doesn’t cause disgrace? This is not to suggest that I ignore my anger, but instead of allowing it to fester and evolve into a grotesque rage, I can create a scenario that expresses my discontent in a reasonable manner. By allowing this passive response to play on repeat in my head, I can rehearse what will happen, and through rehearsal habituate this sort of response.
I can make the choice to change my “visions”. Sure, they will be less dramatic, but this will allow me to live a more joyous, reasonable future, one without moments of embarrassing and damaging rage.
I share this experience because I have heard other people comment on how a situation, “played out exactly as terribly as expected.” If this sort of premonition ever happens to you, I challenge you to face that prediction and try to expect something else. Rehearse a different set of actions in your head and see if you can choose a healthier, happier way to live.
The last entry shared the difference between accepting and appreciating one’s self-identity. As a survivor of 21 years, I have reached the point of appreciation of my identity after brain injury, but it was a long journey. This article will share a summary of my journey to appreciation in the hope that it can provide inspiration.
When the injury happened, I was a high school senior (12th grader) and was already at a transition point in my life. Filled with youthfully ambitious pretension, the plan was to launch out of the small town I felt stuck in and shine my talent upon the world, and when brain injury occurred it delayed my launch date, but I refused to give up the momentum, figuring that “a bump on the head” wouldn’t hold me back. It was temporary. There was a plan prior to the accident and no reason why it couldn’t continue. I was Lethan — the actor — and would move on to at least attempt, and hopefully do, great theatrical things.
But did I still want to be an actor? Didn’t matter, and I didn’t even explore that question. Why should I? I had diligently worked at this craft for half of my long eighteen years — that’s almost a decade of my life (please do read the sarcasm)! It was what I was made to do, my plan, nay, it was my destiny! I was too strong to let this setback damage my core drives, and theater would always be my thing!
I was in denial.
It’s important to recognize that this wasn’t a denial that the brain injury had happened, but I refused to acknowledge that it was a life changing event. I insisted on viewing it as a blip, a skip, a bump in life, and I convinced myself that everything would be back to normal once I healed enough. It just might take a little bit of time. I accepted that the injury occurred, but refused to recognize that it had permanent effects.
And this view was encouraged by other people. Friends, teachers, acquaintances spouting words of encouragement — “Don’t worry, you’ve got this,” — “Strong person like you won’t let this keep you down,” — “You’ll be back to your old self in no time!” I don’t fault anyone for saying these words, as they are what one says to offer support and a positive outlook. More than that, most believed that the words were true, and that was kind, but gave me false expectations. I was convinced that I wouldn’t experience the effects of the accident for all my life, that I would emerge from recovery the same as before.
But this is not how brain injury works. A survivor will almost certainly experience lifelong affects of the injury. Brain injury causes changes. I choose these words carefully, and notice that I do not say, “The survivor was changed by the injury.” The survivor is still the same person, but that person has, and will, continue to experience changes. My performance piece Who Am I, Again? begins and ends with the statement, “I am Lethan.” I use this phrase because it insists on a permanence of self-identity, but that said, a stable self-identity does not mean an unchanging personality. The truth is that every person constantly goes through changes in his or her life — discovering preferences, learning skills, forming relationships — all these and more indicate changes, but it is important that the core identity of a person is recognized as constant. Brain injury causes changes, but it does not change who that person is — I am I.
I emphasize this because learning to adapt to the changes caused by brain injury can create questions about one’s self-identity. It can feel like qualities that are viewed as a necessary part of a person are either no longer present or have fundamentally changed. A survivor may even be conscious of these changes, but not want to acknowledge them because the previous quality is a part of how that person has defined him or herself. This can cause the survivor to cling to former qualities that may have changed as after the injury, and refusing to acknowledge changes may create conflict or stress.
This is confusing, so for clarity, I’m going to explain it again, but in another way.
We all change over the course of life, and most times this change can be accepted because it occurs in a gradual manner. Granted, there may be a few times in every life when, in an instant, there is a “big change” that occurs, but most times we can account for the events that led to this “big moment”. Yet when brain injury occurs, big changes will become apparent throughout the rehabilitation process, but they don’t have the series of surrounding events that add context for these changes. Sure, after brain injury the reason could be stated as, “Well, you had brain injury,” but often the event of the injury isn’t remembered by the survivor, and its hard for an unremembered event to provide sufficient rational for an unbidden change. What’s more, if a survivor is told, “Everything is going to be fine and just like before,” as described above in my experience, unanticipated changes can cause greater confusion, angst, and frustration. This can lead a survivor to attempt to deny that the injury affected his or her life — “Sure, I had brain injury, but I’m fine now. It was just a bump on the head,” — and by not admitting that these changes happened, a survivor may hang onto habits or tendencies that they remember as a defining feature, even if holding onto such a habit is no longer a positive experience.
As explained above, a habit I can clearly cite in my experience that caused me to deny my changes was my love of theater. Sure, I still loved theater after the accident, but didn’t have the same passion, had lost some of the onstage charisma, and the drive to explore the art was completely missing— acting had become a thing that sometimes I did, even though I never felt good about my work. Yet I refused to acknowledge that the need to perform as an actor was no longer a part of who I am.
This did eventually change, but I can’t pick out a specific moment when I decided that I no longer was an actor, as my move from denial and toward acceptance of the new situation was gradual, a change that could be accepted over time. If pressed to provide my rational, I think it grew from not feeling comfortable among my peers in theater, finding a spectacular team of professors at my university that supported me in alternate subjects, and from just trying new things — but I was eventually able to recognize that theater, well... it just wasn’t my thing anymore. My accident had messed up my plans and now I need to do something else.
This was acceptance.
I accepted that my accident had caused changes in both my passions and talents, and these changes hindered my intent to be a stage actor. Now it was time to find something new, and there were many paths to explore — music composition, anthropology, philosophy, sociology, political science, law... Each subjects touched on something I enjoyed, but nothing gripped me the same way theater had — I never felt the same completeness, yet had to accept that the accident had ruined, or at least had changed my relationship with the theater. After all, I was alive, and this was one of the conditions I had to accept in exchange for this life.
Eventually I found Storytelling, and it became a new passion that was a great joy, but it still felt like a substitute. Theater was no longer an option, and I had to accept that now storytelling is what I do. It was a second choice, and one that had to be accepted.
When this acceptance morphed into appreciation is similarly difficult to pinpoint. In Scene 32 of Who Am I, Again, the character of Larry states his realization that his accident, “...kinda made me who I am today, / and I’m okay with that.” For dramatic effect, it would be fun to say that it was this interview that inspired my appreciation, but in truth it was several years after composing the piece when the transition to appreciation fully occurred in my being. What I do know is that the source of this change was recognizing how I could use my experience to help other people. That the injury didn’t need to be something I attempted to ignore while it hampered daily life, but by embracing the experience I could better learn from what had happened and use it as a base from which to build a new life. I came to recognize that the knowledge gained from the injury could help other people who are new to the journey of survival, and by helping others, I am still finding ways to help myself.
Being a survivor is a part of my identity, and I don’t need to hide that. It does not define me, and I will not let it limit me, but I will appreciate the knowledge it has granted me. This does not mean appreciating the injury, but recognizing what the experience has granted — a rare understanding of life that can be used to can help fellow survivors navigate the murk of recovery. By helping others, I can find joy and peace with who I am.
I appreciate who I am and what I am able to share.
Those are my thoughts, and I hope they help you. If you enjoyed, please share this posting and/or leave a comment.